802.11n Line Rate vs. Data Rate - Part 1: Frame Aggregation

802.11n Line Rate vs. Data Rate - Part 1: Frame Aggregation

By CWNP On 10/08/2007 - 6 Comments

Although the PHY layer enhancements (such as MIMO, 40 MHz wide channels and short guard intervals) introduced in 802.11n improve the maximum line rate1 by more than 10x, the MAC layer enhancements (such as frame aggregation) are absolutely essential to achieving data rates that are anything close to the line rate. In this first article, we will briefly examine how data rate (802.11 throughput) is increased by MAC layer enhancements, in particular, we will look at frame aggregation. Without this 802.11n feature, it would not matter what line rate the physical layer achieves – the maximum data rate would be capped by overhead.

For later comparison, let us first examine an 802.11b data transfer. For simplicity, we will look at 802.11 data throughput only, ignoring TCP throughput and throughput at layers above the wireless medium. Say we give our 802.11b STA an ideal world; it is transmitting the maximum payload size (2304 bytes) with every packet, at 11 Mbps (line rate), with short preamble enabled, no encryption and no contention for the medium by other nodes – as fast as an 802.11b node possibly can. As shown in the following figure, the total transaction period for every 2304 bytes is 1938 µsec, or a maximum of 516 transactions per second. Multiplication gets us a raw 802.11 data rate maximum of 9.51 Mbps2

Figure 1 

Looking at the figure above, it is clear that most of the time is spent transmitting the payload data. In fact, 86% of the air time is spent sending data; the remaining 14% is spent in PHY and MAC layer management overhead, such as interframe space, PLCP preamble and ACK.

 

Now, let’s look at transmitting the same 2304 bytes in the best case 802.11n scenario: Let’s also give our example 802.11n STA an almost ideal world; it is transmitting at 600 Mbps (4x4 MIMO, 40 MHz wide channel, short guard interval enabled), and no other contention for the medium. As can be seen in the following figure the total transaction period of every 2304 bytes is 176.91 µsec, or a maximum of 5652 transactions per second. This gets us a raw data rate maximum of 104.19 Mbps.

 

Figure 2

 

Although 104 Mbps is a significant improvement over 9.5 Mbps, we are achieving only 17% of the line rate when expressed as raw data rate. Compare that to 86% of line rate for our 802.11b STA. Looking at the figure above, one may quickly observe that most of the time is spent on overhead, not transferring data. Now, let’s introduce one level of frame aggregation into the picture. MSDU aggregation increases the maximum size of frames from 2304 octets (bytes) to 7935, by aggregating (or combining) frames transported between MAC and LLC layers. As illustrated in the following figure, the transaction period of every 7935 byte packet is just over 250 µsec, giving us a raw maximum data rate of 251.92 Mbps3, or about 42% of our line rate.

 

Figure 3

 

One may casually observe that there is still nearly 60% of overhead. Introducing another level of aggregation, MPDU aggregation solves this. MPDU aggregation increases the maximum frame size from 2304 octets to 65535. As can be noted in the following figure, the 802.11 transaction time for 65535 bytes is just over 1 msec. However, we’re moving a lot more data in that 1 msec, giving us a maximum data rate of 514.01 Mbps, or 86% of line rate – what we were getting with our 802.11b STA.

  Figure 4

 

This demonstrates that not only is frame aggregation an important enhancement to the 802.11 MAC layer, it is absolutely critical if an 802.11n station is to take any real advantage of the High Throughput (HT) PHY layer line rates. It is probably for this reason that frame aggregation is required of all 802.11n devices, both by the IEEE and the Wi-Fi alliance.  

1Line rate: the speed at which data bits are physically transferred over the communications medium.

2 Mega bits per second: Multiply the number of transactions per second, by the number of bytes per transaction, by the number of bits per byte. (2304 x 516.04 x 8 = 9511649.28) 

3
We are ignoring data rate loss due to encapsulation. Also, a single ACK is shown, as opposed to block ACK.

Warren Blackwell is a Sr. Software Engineer at AirMagnet, Inc.

wblackwell@airmagnet.com

http://www.airmagnet.com

"Wireless Network Assurance"

Tagged with: 802.11n

6 Responses to 802.11n Line Rate vs. Data Rate - Part 1: Frame Aggregation

Subscribe by Email
Ralph Raymond Says:
09/12/2018 at 18:03pm
Property accessible for offering in Haciendas Constancia. Individuals who like or intrigued to purchase home in this town then here is great open door for them. In any case, I attempt to think about bestessay.com review and I felt this site have a ton of good data about property offering.

crothermbeme crothermbeme Says:
04/18/2018 at 02:39am
OnCheap Soccer Jerseys Wholesale Friday, Big Deutz - Bryant parted ways with the Dallas Cowboys. Even though Dez continued to reduce Global Jerseys Wholesale production as he ages in the past few years, the eight-year veteran who cut down on the "American team" still let fans debate and enter the free market, and people are guessing that Deze's next stop. Where will it be.New Products
Deez BryantWorld Cup 2018 is very dissatisfied with the practice of the Cowboys. He has been well-trained in the off-season and is only able to play better for the next season.Bundesliga Jerseys Originally they could cut off Detz earlier, but they did not, which made Deez passive in the free market. On Tuesday, Deze told reporters that he wouldShop All Products be happy to stay in the East area of ??the League of Nations. In this case, he would have the opportunity to play against the cowboy twice a Other Teamsyear. He hopes that his old club will achieve revenge. Deez also said that the New York Giants attracted him, especially their offensive team. "The Giants'Premier League offseason lineup is relatively intact and I think they will give OBJ a suitable offer, so Beckham will definitely stay here.
In addition to hisLa Liga offense, there are also Sterling Shepard, near-fielder Irwin Ingram, and Eli Manning. Heaven! This is crazy! "These were followed by Deez and added:" If they takeLigue 1 away Sarkwan Barkley of Penn State in the draft, the offensive team is just as beautiful. "The ideal is full, but the reality is very skinny. If the Giants use BucketNFL Jerseys 2 to pick Buckley, their offensive team would be enough even if they didn't have Deez. The reason for signing him may be that the team needs red zone offensive NHL Jerseysweapons." This is why Deez didn't mention Brandon Marshall when he talked about the Giants offensive team. Last season, Marshall only played for the Giants in fiveNBA Jerseys games and then went on a free-fighting game. If the Giants really signed Dees, then Marshall had a lot. It may become a victim.
In addition to the Giants, Dez NCAA JerseysBryant has a decent interest in several teams, including Jacksonville Jaguars, Oakland Raiders and 49 San Francisco players. So what are the teams he does not Nike NFLwant to go? Green Bay Packers, Deez thinks the team "had too many stories with him." "Green Bay may not be able to deal with me." Deitz pointed out that in the 2015Nike NFL Jerseys postseason, the Cowboys and packers met in a narrow way. In the crucial moment of the fourth quarter, Deez Bryant made a new first pass by passing TonyAuthentic Jerseys Romo in the fourth gear to advance the ball to the yard 1 yard ahead of the packer.
At this time, Packer coach MikeWomen Jerseys McCarthy put forward a challenge. After the referee watched the video, he decided that the receiving ball was invalid, which made Deez very dissatisfied. If theYouth Jerseys ball is placed in the 2018 season, the penalty is definitely another result. Excluding Aaron Rogers's factors, Dez didn't like packers. For Dez Bryant, he does Shop By National Team not want to see the current situation, because he can get at least 12.5 million US dollars to stay in the cowboy, and into the free market will greatly reduce their own value. In recent years, Dez's data is not very beautiful. Coupled with age, the peak period has passed. It may be difficult for Deze's wish list to take place.

Taylor Wilson Says:
03/15/2018 at 08:14am
I need little information about frame aggregation and block ack for Dissertation Propsal Help could anyone help me to vast my knowledge.

Donald Sher Says:
12/29/2017 at 03:50am
wiki.

Vishal Tyagi Says:
12/23/2017 at 02:29am
Mt friend ask me to play these yahtzee game free online and as I have played these games I came to know that these games are the most entertaining games.

Says:
10/13/2007 at 02:33am
http://www.forex.co.ir
http://www.meta-fx.com
forex فاركس

<< prev - comments page 1 of 1 - next >>

Leave a Reply

Please login or sign-up to add your comment.
Success Stories

I literally just came out of the testing centre having taken the CWDP exam. The certification process opened my mind to different techniques and solutions. This knowledge can only broaden your perspective. Great job, CWNP, you have a great thing going on here.

-Darren
Read More

Working through the CWNP coursework and certifications helped not only to deepen my technical knowledge and understanding, but also it boosted my confidence. The hard work it took to earn my CWNE has been rewarding in so many ways.

-Ben
Read More

I want to commend you and all at CWNP for having a great organization. You really 'raise the bar' on knowing Wi-Fi well. I have learned a ton of information that is helping my job experience and personal career goals, because of my CWAP/CWDP/CWSP studies. Kudos to all at CWNP.

-Glenn
Read More