Dynamic Frequency Selection

Dynamic Frequency Selection

By CWNP On 01/21/2010 - 38 Comments

In the beginning stages of my Wi-Fi journey, 802.11h was confusing. Just like everyone else, I was drowning in the world of faceless acronyms. Over time, the meaning of Dynamic Frequency Selection (DFS) started to take on a concrete form and I assimilated the term into my armory. If you’re feeling that way, I wanted to share some thoughts on DFS that should help to secure it in the memory as an important topic.


As a reintroduction, Dynamic Frequency Selection was introduced along with Transmit Power Control by 802.11h back in 2003. DFS came into play as regulatory domains were freeing up more channels, namely the 5.25-5.35 GHz (UNII-2) and 5.47-5.725 (UNII-2e [extended]) GHz frequencies, for WLAN usage. European countries were the initial proponents for DFS requirements, but almost all regulatory domains joined the movement, including the FCC in the US. As with other unlicensed bands, there are other RF occupants in these bands. Military, weather, and aviation radars are all used in this spectrum, and as you might guess, Wi-Fi plays a second fiddle in comparison.

So, the compromise for sharing these frequencies with Wi-Fi devices was to mandate some type of radar detection and avoidance. Hence, we have DFS. To meet the requirements of regulatory domains, WLAN devices operating in these frequencies must perform periodic scans to detect pulses from radars. When a radar signature is detected, the WLAN must avoid interfering on this channel by switching the entire BSS to a new channel. After switching to a new channel, the WLAN must cease transmissions on the previous channel for at least 30 minutes. This requirement applies to client devices as well as APs. In fact, clients that are scanning for an AP in DFS frequencies must wait to hear beacons (passive) before they can transmit a probe request (active).

This may lead you to believe that DFS channels should be avoided altogether, but this is not the intended takeaway. DFS channels can still be used with a significant amount of confidence, but due to the potential impact of radar on these channels, they should be used with caution, and only after testing has been performed. How do you test? Here are a few ideas.

Since radar pulses are only visible at the RF layer, the initial instinct may be to test for radar with a spectrum analyzer. While this is a good second layer of protection and validation, I would encourage that you test for radar by performing pilot phases with the intended infrastructure equipment. If a radar pulse is present, APs operating on that channel will use Channel Switch Announcement (CSA) frames to switch channels. While RF folks probably read that advice and think it’s crazy, I do have some sensible reasoning.

Since there are several types of radar that could be detected, RF signature detection by WLAN infrastructure vendors is not foolproof. In an effort to assure compliance with regulatory domains, AP vendors must be extra cautious when testing for DFS. In other words, if the radar detection is imperfect, it will tend to err on the side of caution. So, it will detect false positives and possibly trigger DFS events when there is no radar. Each vendor develops its DFS recognition method independently, so one vendor may trigger a DFS event while another vendor keeps operating normally—unless there is an actual radar, in which case both vendors should trigger a DFS event. So, you may test with a spectrum analyzer and determine that no radar pulses are present, but then deploy your solution and find that the system is experiencing a large number of false positive DFS events. The implication of this poor design approach is that some amount of redesign is necessary, which may require new channel plans, adjustments in transmit power, and possibly moving, adding, or removing APs. This is a headache, extra cost, and downtime…all bad. By all means, use a spectrum analyzer to detect radars as a part of your design process. But, don’t trust a spectrum analyzer exclusively.

After a careful testing phase, deployment in the DFS channel range could be done with confidence. Of course, if you are deploying in an area near an airport, military facility, or other location where radars are somewhat likely, it would be advisable to simply avoid these channels. Unfortunately, DFS channels make up more than 60% of the available bandwidth of unlicensed 5 GHz for Wi-Fi. Without DFS channels, WLANs are left with only four 40 MHz channels. This may sound sufficient when compared with the three 20 MHz channels in 2.4 GHz, but it’s an unfortunate limitation when you consider the possibility of twenty-four 20 MHz channels or eleven 40 MHz channels.

GT Hill also has a nice video discussing DFS if you’d like a helpful visual treatment of the topic. http://www.youtube.com/gthillwifi


38 Responses to Dynamic Frequency Selection

Subscribe by Email
Best Writer Says:
09/21/2018 at 02:24am
Each day I am realizing that the online forum is the best platform for sharing of ideas. I am grateful that I have the privilege to read this wonderful post. Visit our firm to buy Cheap article writing services and also
muneer ahmed Says:
09/17/2018 at 18:08pm
He should know the request of outside trade and need of earnest exchange assentions of highlow. Highlow

muneer ahmed Says:
09/14/2018 at 10:29am
The amusement propels with the croupier turning the haggle winning number is chosen by observing the position where the ball stops. ma chance

perry george Says:
08/29/2018 at 08:33am
By the time you are applying, you probably cannot significantly alter your GPA or LSAT score. Thus, if your numbers make you a “borderline candidate” – someone who could be admitted but could just as easily be rejected – your personal statement is your greatest opportunity to swing the decision in your favor. As one Director of Admissions put it: “If someone with your numbers has a possibility of being admitted to a particular school, but not everyone with your numbers is admitted to that school, the major deciding factor is the personal statement.”

On the other hand, even if you seem like a shoo-in – you have, for example, a perfect GPA and a 180 on the LSAT – a weak personal statement is damning. Indeed, nothing looks worse than a candidate with perfect numbers and no personality – or, worse, who exhibits a lack of effort on their application. As an admissions officer from Yale Law School lamented: “When a candidate with perfect numbers writes a less than impressive personal statement, we either throw their application out entirely or send it to the borderline pile.”

essay writers uk

Carl Lee Says:
08/27/2018 at 08:19am
All you got to do is visit this essay writing service https://midnightpapers.com/ and order your paper. This would be a right solution.

muneer ahmed Says:
08/19/2018 at 07:18am
In case you're one of the shrewd online gambling club players, at that point this would be an astute choice to take in more clubhouse procedures playing as well as by perusing the pertinent data through the Web. Mr smith

muneer ahmed Says:
08/18/2018 at 15:51pm
The distinctive amusements played in gambling clubs have a scientific base which is agreeable to the clubhouse. machance casino

daisy walker Says:
08/16/2018 at 01:51am
In numerous nations, administrative necessities may restrain the quantity of 5 GHz channels accessible or put extra limitations on their utilization in light of the fact that the range is imparted to different advancements and administrations. For example, in the US and different nations, a portion of the Unlicensed National Information Infrastructure (U-NII) groups are utilized by radar frameworks. Wi-Fi systems working in those groups are required to utilize a radar recognition and evasion capacity. The IEEE 802.11h standard tends to this necessity by including support for DFS and transmit control (TPC) on each DFS channel. understudies task help is the best Choice for British Custom Essay| The Best Essy Writing Service In UK. We offer Expert Writers from different parts of the UK and they had done their Ph.D. also, Master's degrees from top colleges of the UK

afsa ishu Says:
08/10/2018 at 06:08am
atdonline

atdonline phone number

atdonline wheels

atd wholesale

atdonline tire login

atdonline online

aftab ali Says:
08/01/2018 at 04:27am
Keeping in mind the end goal to defeat the players from pulling back cash before betting and playing in a diversion that is limited, the betting necessities are forced on them. tipico

muneer ahmed Says:
07/30/2018 at 07:12am
Visit an accomplished Forex merchant who has involvement in the issue with impressive achievement in the same. finmax

Maitri Shah Says:
07/30/2018 at 06:45am
free gift card generator

Elecia Wilson Says:
07/26/2018 at 06:55am
Natural selection works a shot at transformations that are now set up. The ecological changes will choose for specific transformations if the particular weight is provided sufficiently long for a few ages of posterity to convey a higher level of the change.

Regards: cheap essay help uk

muneer ahmed Says:
07/23/2018 at 15:25pm
Pick up everything that you can about the universe of football failures and football lay wagering. sportnation

Elecia Wilson Says:
07/18/2018 at 04:21am
A debt of gratitude is in order for setting aside time for sharing this article, it was astounding and exceptionally enlightening. It is extremely exceptionally helpful for the greater part of the clients. I found a great deal of educational stuff in your article. Keep it up.

Regards: assignment writing service uk

Taniya Khan Says:
07/16/2018 at 01:00am
I personally like your post, you have shared a good article. It will help me in a great deal.
Delhi Escorts

muneer ahmed Says:
07/08/2018 at 11:32am
Also, the more fulfilled your Sim is, the all the more effectively you would have the capacity to gain more Simoleons in less time. nightrush

muneer ahmed Says:
07/07/2018 at 13:17pm
I have looked couple of days and discovered some spellbinding formed work on it. In any case, it is the best of all. 1xbet

aftab ali Says:
07/07/2018 at 12:57pm
Along these lines you can factor in the circumstance when you wager. Betfair

muneer ahmed Says:
06/17/2018 at 22:30pm
I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post movierulz

muneer ahmed Says:
06/02/2018 at 03:41am
I am come here first time, i find the perfect article. Thanks for sharing interesting and informative post. storspelare

muneer ahmed Says:
05/31/2018 at 04:55am
Man's lives, such as uncontrolled huge amounts, definitely not while countries furthermore reefs, challenging to seismic disturbance upward perfect apply. iq option

John Shepherd Says:
05/15/2018 at 02:37am
I concur with Marcus on this one. Without delving into every one of the points of interest, having the capacity to precisely decide if a flag on a range analyzer is a TRUE radar flag includes a great deal of involvement, and the capacity to change certain settings on the analyzer. Some dissertation writing services less expensive analyzers don't enable you to change such settings.

walmart credit Says:
05/14/2018 at 12:03pm
Walmart, the most profitable retailer in the USA, also offers two credit cards for its customers. Synchrony Bank issues both the cards.

Walmart credit card login usa

harry james Says:
05/10/2018 at 06:06am
Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! sadhana sindhanur

zhen12 zhen12 Says:
05/01/2018 at 22:36pm
February 24th, 2004: 1st Round of 1/8 Finals - The Only Handshake
This was the first time that Real Madrid had left Munich as a loser. NFL Jerseys Ma Kai's header made Bayern almost beat Real Madrid again. Unfortunately, Carlos's classic 30-meter free kick reopened Kahn's guarded door when the game left with 7 minutes.NFL Cheap Sports Jerseys Eventually the two sides made a 1:1 handshake. "We were lucky," said Real Madrid's midfielder Zidane, who was at the time. At the time, Bayern coach Hitzfeld said: "We taught Real Madrid how to write the word 'fear'."
March 7, 2007: 1/8 Final Round - Makai Lightning Breaks
This is the first time in Bayern Munich to enter the Allianz Arena in the Champions League "hospitality" Real Madrid - giving opponents the fastest time in the Champions League conceded.Adidas NHL Jersey Thomas Muller later recalled this classic goal from Makai: Adidas NBA Swingman Jersey "Brazo (Salihamidzic) broke the right, passed in, boomed, and scored the ball." The overshoot took 10.12 seconds!Stitched NCAA Hockey Jersey So far this fastest goal record has not been broken. In the second half, CFL Jersey knife guard Lucio used the corner kick to expand the score to 2-0, after which Fannie entered a controversial penalty that made the game tense again. Van Bommel and Diarra had two yellows and one red. Ramos scored a goal in the last minutes of the scent,Flex Base Baseball Jersey but was penalized for handball. In the end, Bayern beat Real Madrid 2-1 (2:3 in the first round) to advance with a goal scoring advantage.April 17,Soccer Club Jersey 2012: The first round of the semi-finals - Gomez continues Bayern's dream
After five years, Real Madrid Bayern met again and the last few minutes of the match were still very exciting.Women Jersey The Champions League final was held at the Allianz Arena with the dream of returning home in the Champions League. Bayern took the lead in the 17th minute and Franck Ribery took the lead to score the second half. Kier helped Real Madrid to equalize, Gomez scored the final seconds of the game so that Allianz Arena 66,000 home fans into madness. Youth Jersey "This is a passionate game. Real Madrid has proved that he is a great team. At the last moment we can win 2-1 with a bit of luck. We can be proud of our victory," Custom Jersey said Rummenigge after the game.April 29, 2014: Semi-final second round - Real Madrid defeats Bayern for the first time0:1 loss to Real Madrid Bayern had a big mountain to cross at home.Nike Pas Cher Outlet "Everything will burn in Munich in Munich" This is a rhetoric released by Rummenigge before the game. However, the results are very different: 20 minutes later, Bayern has fallen behind 0:2, Ramos scored twice. Adidas shoe "We planned a lot but didn't notice the two most standard conditions," said Ram after the game. At the end of halftime, Ronaldo scored another goal and Crome took a second stoppage. Real Madrid expanded the winning streak and defeated the ten rivals of the Madrid City AFC Champions League in the final.April 12,Nike Air Force One 2017: First round of the quarter-finals - reversal of Real Madrid Allianz Arena
The two sides played against each other at the Allianz Arena and Real Madrid brought misfortune to Bayern.Nike Air Huarache However, Bayern's start is quite good: In the 25th minute, Bidar headed for Bayern to lead.Nike Air Jordan At the end of the half he was even expected to change the score to 2:0, but he missed the penalty. Bayern wasted the opportunity to pay the price of bearing.Nike Air Max Cristiano Ronaldo reached the score in the second half of the opening match. In the 61st minute, Martinez was sent off. In 77 minutes, NMD R1 shoe Crome opened twice and Real Madrid reversed Bayern. After Ram’s conclusion: “The match turned sharply after being equalized. Both yellow and red are the turning points of the game.”

JASMINE LEE Says:
05/01/2018 at 02:10am Attachment: Download newintrends.jpg

Great post and useful so. If you want to grab some money on the camera, mobile phone, and fashion clothing visit my site
newintrends
Thanks for visiting.

Alicia Newman Says:
04/25/2018 at 17:41pm
That relies upon the merchant execution. Some will just change channels on the off chance that you have them set to "auto." On the off chance that you've physically indicated a channel, the same number of people have a tendency to do, a few units will essentially close down on a radar occasion. They're permitted to return online some time later, subsequent to filtering to check whether the radar is gone, yet that could be minutes/hours/days/never.

In the event that you focus on the range maps/graphs it's conceivable to pick DFS channels that are more averse to be utilized. That is the reason I loved the TWDR site over; there's no genuine reason for utilizing a TWDR frequency when they're a matter of open record. The greatest "portable" factor is marine radars, which will be a non-issue for the vast majority of the nation. I trust there's some avionics utilization also, yet unless you're close to an airplane terminal it's not prone to be an issue. Obviously, you can utilize "auto," and most likely ought to in case you're a non-nerd, yet I like to have control over my stuff....

My inclination isn't to utilize DFS channels by any means, yet in the event that you live in a thick domain like a flat complex that may not be a choice. Dissertation Help Indeed, even in my rural setting I can at present "hear" different systems (four of them on Channel 36!) on each non-DFS channel. Gratefully, not a solitary one of them is sufficiently noisy to truly cause me issues. Each DFS channel is clear, which shocks me to be completely forthright, and I could utilize them in the event that I was so disposed, likely without issue, yet at my present area it's not yet a squeezing need..

Kevinogi jhome Says:
04/18/2018 at 05:11am
Manfred said he didn't know that the Marlins' new owners planned to tear it washington nationals jersers down
In the early moments of atlanta braves jersers the interview, Le Batard asked Manfred whether he knew prior to the recent sale to the group oakland athletics jersers fronted by Bruce Sherman and Jeter whether the new owners planned to slash payroll. After some prodding (and Le Batard's saying that the commissioner was lying), Manfred answered, "We do not get involved in operating-level decisions in the ownership approval process."

"We did not have player-specific plans from the Miami Marlins or any other team that has been in the ownership miami marlins jersers process. Those are decisions that the individual owners make, and they do not have to be cleared by us or approved by us. ... Those are local decisions that really are not part of the approval process. Those are decisions that the individual owners make, and they do not have to be cleared with us or approved by us."

Manfred went on to say that he didn't receive a payroll plan from the Marlins until two days prior to his interview with Le Batard. More: "We don't get into, are you going to trade 'Player X' or 'Player Y' at a particular point in time, nor do we ask them to make a commitment to people before they even got in and made an evaluation of their talent level, their ability to win with the people that st. louis cardinals jersers they have. That's just not how the ownership process works."
wholesale baseball jersers

But some of that may not be true
Here's a key excerpt from a los angeles angels of anaheim jersers must-read Barry Jackson piece in the Miami Herald:

A source directly involved in the Marlins sales chicago white sox jersers process, after hearing the Le Batard cincinnati reds jersers interview, said, via text: "Commissioner said was not aware of [Jeter] plan to slash payroll. Absolutely not true. They request and receive the operating plan from all bidders.

"Project Wolverine [the name for Jeter's plan] called chicago white sox jersers on his group to reduce payroll to $85 million. This was vetted and approved by MLB prior to approval by MLB. Every [Jeter] investor and non investor has the Wolverine financial plan of slashing payroll to $85 million. Widely circulated."

First off, "Project Wolverine" is ludicrously self-important and sinister-sounding, as budget strategies go. That's the name of a secret NSA laboratory deep under the Caballo Mountains in New Mexico, not a financial schematic. Do better, Jeets. Anyhow, there's enough careful phrasing in Manfred's comments ("operating-level decisions," "'Player X' or 'Player Y'") to give him some plausible deniability. However, the idea that he didn't know about plans to engage in yet another demo job by Marlins owners strains credulity.

crothermbeme crothermbeme Says:
04/18/2018 at 02:55am
On Monday,NFL jersesys shop US local time, the New England Patriots began their first voluntary activity in the offseason. Many media have focused their attention on the absence of quarterbackShop NFL Jerseys By Team Tom Brady and near-fielder Rob Gronkowski. However, the return of a key player deserves the same level of attention. He is the wide receiver - JulianBuy Customized NFL Jerseys Edelman. On Monday, Edelman appeared in the Gillette Stadium. This was his first step toward a $500,000 training bonus.Shop NFL Hats
The amount Shop NFL T-Shirtsof this bonus ranks first in the Patriot team. The following is the comparison of Edelman's total training bonus with other players in the team: Edelman:Shop NFL Hoodie $500,000 in Glonnowski: $250,000 Kickback Goalbacker Kodarel Patterson: $250,000 in defense Endpoints Lawrence Guy: $200,000 kicker Stephen Gestkowski: $100,000Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys security guard Patrick Bell (Clock family): $85,000 In addition to the bonus, Edelman's appearance is also A positive signal was Minnesota Vikings Jerseysreleased: He was recovering systematically from the anterior cruciate ligament tear injury on August 25 last year. With Brandine Cooks Customized Seattle Seahawks Jerseysbeing traded by the team, Danny Amundola joined the Miami Dolphins again through the free agency market. As Brady’s numberCustomized Carolina Panthers Jerseys one goal, Edelman’s return to health in the new season is The Patriots' top priority. As a rule, Brady and Edelman hadIndianapolis Colts Hats practiced many passes during this offseason.
In addition, Edelman’s move Tampa Bay Buccaneersto Gillette Stadium on Monday was also a balance between strength training and Brady’s personal trainer Alex Guerrero. Edelman, who willSeattle Seahawks Hoodie soon turn 32, is a frequent guest of the TB12 Sports Therapy Center founded by Guerrero.
It is reported that Brady may reduceLos Angeles Chargers Hoodie the frequency of participating in the Patriots training during this offseason, and will pay more attention to his training withBaltimore Ravens T-shirts Guerrero. From the current situation, Edelman does not seem to have similar ideas with Brady. (TB12 is Tom Brady's English initialsAtlanta Falcons T-shirts and jersey number.) If you don't remember what Elderman's Patriots lost last season, perhaps the following three facts can remind Denver Broncos T-shirtsyou of Edelman’s Importance: 1. He collected data in 89 postseason games, ranking third in NFL history, second only to Jerry Rice's 151Jacksonville Jaguars Hoodie and Reggie Wayne's 93.
This also means that as long as Edelman completed Los Angeles Rams Hatsfive postseason catches, he will surpass Wayne and rank second in history. 2. He was one of 14 players who completed at least 1000 yardsCustomized New England Patriots Jerseys of NFL postseason advancement and ranked 13th in NFL history with 1024 yards of data. As long as Edelman finished San Francisco 49ers Jerseyscatching the ball in the 39-yard playoffs, he will be ranked in the top ten in history. 3. In his career, a total of four postseasonArizona Cardinals Jerseys games have completed single-field catches and advanced over 100 yards. In this data, he and Dion - Blanche together, ranked first in the history of the Patriots.

Pierson man Says:
04/06/2018 at 07:56am
The frequency selection is on-point here and I am pleased with your post. If you can tell us about the http://www.essayangels.net/ site now, it would help me out a lot. Your writing skills need to be put into use more and more.

Anna Shetty Says:
03/30/2018 at 00:28am
Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.
cool math games

Jerold Winslow Says:
03/22/2018 at 01:31am
students assignment help is the best Choice for assignment help UK. We offer Expert Writers from various parts of the UK and they had done their Ph.D. and Master’s degrees from top universities of the UK.

Taylor Wilson Says:
03/07/2018 at 07:22am
Systems administration is a craftsmanship, of interconnecting assorted figuring device to share and course data. the data is transferring is characterized in light of the reality the particular conventions, as an event web is conventionally connected with on TCP convention, wifi contrasts in real area, wifi makes utilization of on the spot transmission of data by capability of utilization of radio waves, it transmit data to group by methods for a group get admission to component. Dissertation Editing Service

Kr Ashwin Says:
01/11/2018 at 05:02am
Time and date is always need to work properly and this is the learning place where you can fix your Windows 10 clock setting with the help of some tips through this update clock windows 10 and this cost nothing for the information and the short keys.Thank you.

Says:
09/16/2011 at 07:04am
can any one tell me how radar signals are detected ?

Says:
01/21/2010 at 10:18am
I agree with Marcus on this one. Without going into all the details, being able to accurately determine whether a signal on a spectrum analyzer is a TRUE radar signal involves a lot of experience, and the ability to adjust certain settings on the analyzer. Some cheaper analyzers do not even allow you to adjust such settings.

The CSA is a very powerful "tool" in determining what is going on.

Just to re-iterate: provided you are not near an airport or military base etc, it is most likely that DFS "radar detects" are just some other form of energy/interference.

I would recommend trying to check where it is coming from, just as you would with any old interference as previously [ pre.11h ]. An antenna/spec an combination can help. If you can find the source, you might be able to get the people responsible to work with you [ perhaps adjusting power levels etc ]. I've done this many times, just being pleasant to the other parties. "Hi...I'm working down the road, and we're having some problems with our Wi-Fi system....I wonder if you could please try and help us....".Most folks will try to help if they can.

Dave

<< prev - comments page 1 of 1 - next >>

Leave a Reply

Please login or sign-up to add your comment.
Success Stories

I literally just came out of the testing centre having taken the CWDP exam. The certification process opened my mind to different techniques and solutions. This knowledge can only broaden your perspective. Great job, CWNP, you have a great thing going on here.

-Darren
Read More

Working through the CWNP coursework and certifications helped not only to deepen my technical knowledge and understanding, but also it boosted my confidence. The hard work it took to earn my CWNE has been rewarding in so many ways.

-Ben
Read More

I want to commend you and all at CWNP for having a great organization. You really 'raise the bar' on knowing Wi-Fi well. I have learned a ton of information that is helping my job experience and personal career goals, because of my CWAP/CWDP/CWSP studies. Kudos to all at CWNP.

-Glenn
Read More