WLAN Controllers and Fast Secure Roaming

WLAN Controllers and Fast Secure Roaming

By CWNP On 01/03/2012 - 18 Comments

The title is deceptive. Now that I have you thinking about WLAN controllers and fast secure roaming, my goal in this short post is to point out why WLAN controllers do not sufficiently address fast secure roaming. Why must I write such an article? Because in the past six months, I’ve read article after article claiming that the cure to fast secure roaming problems is a WLAN controller. IT IS NOT! I have nothing against controllers per se; I just want to set the record straight. My point is actually twofold.

Point #1
Even with a WLAN controller, the state of fast secure roaming in Wi-Fi is quite poor. Today’s roaming options are sub-optimal (understatement alert!!!) and any significant solutions have been slow, slow, slow to market, like watching a cactus grow. WLAN controllers don’t fix this because they can’t control the clients or the client vendors. Inconsistent clients are typically the real problem!
Point #2
The best roaming options today are not a result of controllers. Preauthentication is actually not a terrible protocol. It’s a little inefficient, but it would work if folks would use it. It works on any architecture (autonomous included), but I know of only one infrastructure vendor and very few client vendors that support it. OKC is a solid protocol, but again, very few clients support it.
Cisco’s proprietary CCKM protocol (part of the CCX program) happens to use a WLAN controller, but that’s not why it works. It works because Cisco has market share and can influence client vendors to implement the feature. Any vendor with any architecture could specify a proprietary protocol that works, but none other than Cisco have the business muscle to make it useful, and Cisco happens to be a controller vendor.
Meru’s proprietary single channel design essentially eliminates the need for client control of roaming. They remove the weak link in the chain. Meru’s design is more dependent on a controller, but once again, the fast secure roaming problem is not solved by a WLAN controller. For Meru, it is solved by using a single channel and a single BSSID across all APs.
And I suppose I should make the obligatory point that any other good-but-not-widely-or-consistently-supported roaming protocols work equally well with a cooperative autonomous WLAN (i.e. Aerohive). WLAN controllers simply do not fix the roaming problem.
The Solution
The Wi-Fi Alliance members could help the disheveled state of roaming by adopting and promoting Voice Enterprise. Voice Enterprise has technical merit, is based on public specifications (802.11r and 802.11k), would lead to consistent implementation, and would drive better adoption among vendors by virtue of Wi-Fi Alliance certification. But lo, we wait.
Final Comments and Suggestions (FCS)
WLAN controllers fix the roaming problem. WLAN controllers fix the roaming problem. WLAN controllers fix the roaming problem. WLAN controllers fix the roaming problem….. You can keep saying it, but it’s still not true.
WLAN controllers are not the solution to fast secure roaming. They’re not. The real solutions are simple enough:
  1. Use PSKs,
  2. Build a widely supported, publicly documented, certifiable, efficient set of protocols for key management across an Extended Service Set (i.e. Voice Enterprise), or
  3. Use proprietary protocols
Controllers aren’t bad, but buying one won't fix your roaming problems.
  Tagged with: marketing, roaming, Mobility, WLAN controllers, fast transition

18 Responses to WLAN Controllers and Fast Secure Roaming

Subscribe by Email

alice long Says:
02/06/2018 at 00:08am
Sage +1 888 336 0774 community, Intuit Payroll community and Intuit Sage community can be subscribed to free of cost. Sage Sage Customer Support Phone Numberand TurboTax have dedicated websites where users can search for any sort of services they need. So how this support does really works? No rocket science. The user just has to submit his/her query and wait for the responses from other users to get posted.

alice long Says:
02/06/2018 at 00:04am
I've been a power user of QuickBooks +1 888 336 0774 for over 20 yearsQuickBooks Tech Support Phone Number and it is because it is constantly growing to meet the ever changing needs of their users.

alice long Says:
02/06/2018 at 00:00am
They claim to provide prompt, 24x7 round the clock, and on Quicken Technical Support Numberdemand remotely accessed diagnosis to their subscribed customers. The author has been writing articles about Intuit customer suppor +1 888 336 0774 and about various ways of obtaining it since several years. He also publishes articles for Intuit customer service and other Intuit products from time to time

Lucy Gray Says:
02/05/2018 at 00:22am
Sage Tech Support Number Business Care : Official administrations gave by SAGE Inc. to their elite client with Silver, Gold and Platinum designs SAGE open new space for the client which included Knowledgebase, Sage City distributed help,Chat,Premium telephone support, Anytime learning courses, Sage Payroll Services, Upgrade arranging assistance, Appointment scheduling, Proactive help calls, Sage University constant training, Checks and forms, Sage Time, Sage Intelligence Reporting, Sage CRM,Sage Inventory Advisor Basics, Processing discount, Sage Summit.Sage Tech Support Phone Number Call +1-844-454-7202 to Get Sage 100 Technical Support .

Lucy Gray Says:
02/05/2018 at 00:15am
Quicken Support You should have web access keeping in mind the end goal to utilize our benefit. Since Quicken Technical Support is an online help. Revive Support Phone number is the most ideal approach to get the answer for your Quicken Technical Support Number problem. It doesn't what amount muddled is your concern; you can dial Quicken enable telephone to number with no delay.

Lucy Gray Says:
02/05/2018 at 00:07am
Be that as it may, this site is devoted for a particular programming technology, or as it were "Programming Interface" which is extraordinary in its own kind. Here we are discussing the most utilized and trusted bookkeeping genius Software Quickbooks Technical Support Number +1-844-454-7202.

anjilo smith Says:
02/03/2018 at 06:29am
Sage 50 Support Phone Number +1-888-307-3506
Which are additionally affirmed Sage experts offering expanded help and help on bookkeeping issues. All the above work defended our level of aptitude in Sage, commitment, energy and client driven approach. Sage Tech Support Number
Sage Tech Support Phone Number You get similar administrations from Sage Ltd too yet Sage won't have the capacity to offer Windows Support or Mac Support or OS issues causing issues in Sage.

anjilo smith Says:
02/03/2018 at 06:06am
Quicken Technical Support Number +1-888-307-3506
Since Quicken Technical Support is an online help. Quicken Tech Support Number
Quicken Tech Support Phone Number Animate Support Phone number is the most ideal approach to get the answer for your Quicken problem. It doesn't what amount confused is your concern, you can dial Quicken enable telephone to number with no dithering. 1-888-307-3506 additionally function as Quicken client bolster telephone number.

anjilo smith Says:
02/03/2018 at 05:48am
QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-888-307-3506
It computerizes the business bookkeeping and makes it simpler to oversee everyday bookkeeping errands. Breaking the customary hindrances of procuring experts and bookkeepers to work for a considerable length of time, Quickbooks Support Number
Quickbooks Support Phone Number QuickBooks has helped in sparing cash from enlisting experts and made bookkeeping simpler and speedier with only a couple of snaps. We are here to help and guide you in understanding QuickBooks so you can utilize it in the most ideal way and deal with your accounts.

Olivia Smith Says:
02/02/2018 at 05:41am
Antivirus Customer Service Phone Number is here to help. Call +1888-451-1608 Norton Antivirus Support Phone Number for all kind of technical and support queries. Norton Antivirus Technical Support Phone Number so that you don't forget to turn it on while accessing the internet. In addition, despite the fact that each of these programs provides adequate security in itself, Mcafee Antivirus Tech Support Phone Number your system can become unstable if you try to run more than one antivirus program at the same time.

Olivia Smith Says:
02/02/2018 at 05:16am
Microsoft Outlook Customer Support is here to help. Call +1-888-451-1608 Microsoft Outlook Support Phone Number for all kind of technical and support queries. When the Outlook Express 5 was introduced, in its beta version, there was a complicated spam filtering feature. Considering its intricate structure, the feature was soon removed. Outlook Customer Service Number The reason for its deletion was its lesser effect on mass market.

Olivia Smith Says:
02/02/2018 at 05:00am
Aol Customer Support Number is here to help. Call +1-888-451-1608 for Mail correction, reset, forget password, account disable and unable, send or receive mail.It simply does not work that way. Here is another potential surprise for you; the programs you were running on Windows XP may require an update when you move to Windows 7. Aol Technical Support Phone Number It is very likely that you now have a 64 bit operating system, where you had a 32 bit operating system on your old computer.

Sara Marchetti Says:
01/19/2018 at 03:18am
Thanks for the great post. Pretty good post.
I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.
I would like more information about this, because it is very interesting. Thanks for sharing.

01/25/2012 at 09:56am
Amen. The thing I can't understand is why no one is pushing Android and IOS devices to support CCKM or 802.11r. The vowifi handset market would dry out within a year Apple or Google came out with an enterprise level SIP dialing setup that could fast roam. I'd buy a million

Howard Higgins Says:
01/04/2012 at 17:11pm
My problem with "voice enterprise" is the name.
I have several devices that need fast roaming - but they have nothing to do with "voice". Or the CTIA for that matter.
I need WMM-PS and therefore WMM for power savings. Now I need another certification (voice-ent.) to get/claim decent roaming?
Every WFA certification costs more $ and time. Multiply that by a number of models and things have really gotten out of hand.
I suggest a new classification - something like "what Wi-Fi should have done to begin with", and wrap all this up in one new certification.
Afterall, who would want any kind of device that burns up batteries, and can't roam properly anyway?

Daniel Bui Says:
01/04/2012 at 02:42am
Finally, Someone has the cajones to tell it like it is! Fast roaming is definitely a client issue. The closest company that got it right is Meru but I never thought the solution would be scalable. You're right, if we could get the WiFi alliance to certify fast roaming?

01/03/2012 at 18:20pm
Here, here! Standards-based fast roaming and adoption is sorely needed.
I would also point out that Cisco's CCKM worked long before controllers existed on Autonomous APs. Let's not forget that Cisco's WLCCP protocol and CCKM were "cooperative-control" light. Okay, not even quite that, but on the right track at least ;)
Andrew vonNagy

<< prev - comments page 1 of 1 - next >>

Leave a Reply

Please login or sign-up to add your comment.
Success Stories

I literally just came out of the testing centre having taken the CWDP exam. The certification process opened my mind to different techniques and solutions. This knowledge can only broaden your perspective. Great job, CWNP, you have a great thing going on here.

Read More

Working through the CWNP coursework and certifications helped not only to deepen my technical knowledge and understanding, but also it boosted my confidence. The hard work it took to earn my CWNE has been rewarding in so many ways.

Read More

I want to commend you and all at CWNP for having a great organization. You really 'raise the bar' on knowing Wi-Fi well. I have learned a ton of information that is helping my job experience and personal career goals, because of my CWAP/CWDP/CWSP studies. Kudos to all at CWNP.

Read More